On this page
Markers for GMGT5163 Assignment 1 reward a short list of well-evidenced, ranked external factors, not a long list of trends. Pick one Malaysian company, define one industry and one market, use the same sources for the company and its two rivals, and let the PESTEL, Five Forces and EFE matrix feed one clear recommendation that you can defend on video.
This guide explains how to plan each part of the UNIRAZAK group report and video so the marks line up. Need help getting started with your group’s company choice? You can submit your brief for a quote at any stage.
What the Brief Really Asks
The assessment is a group report worth 80 marks and a video worth 20, together 30 per cent of the course. Read the full wording on the GMGT5163 Assignment 1 question page. In plain terms, it asks you to:
- Define the company’s competitive position and show how one corporate-level and one business-level decision affect its ability to sustain advantage.
- Evaluate the three most material macro-environmental developments, not every PESTEL box.
- Apply Porter’s Five Forces to the industry and justify the two forces that matter most.
- Compare the company with two direct competitors on three success factors using one verification standard, and explain how you handled a conflicting or incomplete source.
- Build an EFE matrix with at least six factors, weights summing to 1.00, ratings, weighted scores and a total.
- Interpret the score, compare two strategic responses, recommend one and say how you would react to evidence that weakens it.
- In the video, show a visual of benefit against feasibility, separate verified claims from assumptions, and let each member defend or revise a claim.
The brief does not state a word count, so ask your lecturer or check the course guide before you plan length. Referencing is APA 7th edition and similarity must not exceed 25 per cent.
Mark Split and Where Effort Should Go
| Part | Marks | Format | What earns the top band |
|---|---|---|---|
| Competitive position | 15 | Report | Clear position statement and a causal link from two decisions to sustained advantage |
| PESTEL | 15 | Report | Three ranked developments, each with evidence and an effect on the firm |
| Five Forces | 10 | Report | Two forces justified with industry evidence, not five generic paragraphs |
| Competitor comparison | 10 | Report | Same sources for all three firms and a stated way of handling a weak source |
| EFE matrix | 15 | Report | Correct arithmetic and a justification for the two largest weights |
| Interpretation and recommendation | 15 | Report | Two real options, one choice, and a plan for disconfirming evidence |
| Visual comparison | 10 | Video | Benefit and feasibility shown, verified versus assumed claims marked |
| Member defence | 10 | Video | Every member answers a challenge and names evidence that would change the position |
The bands run from Exceeds (85 to 100 per cent) through Mastery, Near and Below. Most groups lose marks between Near and Mastery because they describe instead of prioritise.
Step-by-Step Plan for Your Group
- Choose the company late enough to have data, early enough to share work. A company with a recent annual report and Bursa Malaysia announcements is easier to evidence. Confirm that two direct competitors also publish enough information.
- Define the industry and the market in one sentence each. “Ready-to-drink coffee in Peninsular Malaysia” is workable. “Food and beverage in Asia” is not.
- Build one shared evidence log. Record source, date, page and what it supports. This log answers the “conflicting or incomplete source” question and protects you in the video defence.
- Draft the PESTEL as a long list, then cut to three. Score each factor on size of profit effect and timing. Keep the top three and state why the rest were dropped.
- Do the Five Forces next. Rate every force briefly, then spend your words on the two that matter.
- Benchmark the competitors. Choose three success factors that actually differ across the firms, such as distribution reach, price position or product range.
- Build the EFE from the earlier sections. Every factor should already have appeared in your PESTEL, Five Forces or benchmark.
- Write the recommendation and script the video together. The visual and the defence should reuse the report’s evidence.
If your group is stuck on the structure, a worked layout helps. Our GMGT5163 PESTEL, Five Forces and EFE sample (for reference only) shows one way to lay it out using a fictional Malaysian beverage company.
Section Guidance
Competitive Position and Two Decisions
State where the firm wins and where it is exposed, then pick one corporate-level decision (which businesses to be in, how to fund them) and one business-level decision (how to compete in one market, such as pricing or channel choice). For each, say what it does to the firm’s ability to keep an advantage that rivals cannot easily copy.
PESTEL
Choose developments that are specific and recent. Malaysian examples that markers recognise include changes to the sales and service tax, minimum wage rises, ringgit movements, Bank Negara Malaysia’s policy rate decisions, halal certification rules and sector-specific levies. Check the current figure before you quote it; a rate or threshold copied from an old article is an easy mark to lose. For each development write three things: what changed, the evidence, and the effect on this firm’s revenue, cost or risk.
Porter’s Five Forces
Apply the model to the industry, not the company. Then connect the two strongest forces to the firm’s choices. If buyer power is high because a few retail chains dominate, what does that mean for pricing and product range?
Competitor Comparison
The key phrase in the brief is “same verification standard”. If you use the annual report for your company, use the equivalent filing for each rival. If a rival is private and publishes little, say so, use the best available proxy, and mark that score lower confidence. Showing how you treated a conflicting figure, for example two different store counts, is a direct mark.
EFE Matrix
List opportunities and threats separately, give each a weight between 0 and 1 with the total exactly 1.00, rate the firm’s current response from 1 to 4, multiply, and add. The average score is 2.50. A total above 2.50 means the firm responds better than average and below means worse. Always justify the two largest weights in a sentence or two, with evidence, because the brief asks for it. Another point to remember: the rating describes the firm’s response, not how big the opportunity or threat is. That size belongs in the weight.
Quick check before you submit: add up the weights twice, recompute each weighted score and verify the total in a spreadsheet.
Interpretation and Recommendation
Do not just say “the score is 2.7, so we are average”. Name which factors drag the score down and what the two strategic responses would do to those ratings. Choose one and say plainly what evidence would make you switch.
Mark-Maximising Checklist
- One company, one industry, one geographic market, stated in the first paragraph.
- Three PESTEL developments with evidence and an effect on the firm.
- Two Five Forces named as most constraining, with reasons.
- Same source types for the company and both competitors.
- A sentence on how you handled one conflicting or incomplete source.
- At least six EFE factors, weights that sum to 1.00, and correct weighted total.
- Justification for the two largest weights.
- Two responses compared; one recommended.
- A video visual that marks verified claims and assumptions.
- Every member speaks and defends or revises a claim.
- APA 7th edition citations and similarity under 25 per cent.
Common Mistakes
- Listing trends. A twelve-row PESTEL with no ranking reads as generic.
- Five Forces on the company. The model describes the industry.
- Weights that do not add to 1.00 or rounding that leaves 0.99 or 1.02.
- Treating the rating as the importance of the factor. Importance is the weight.
- Different evidence standards. Using the annual report for your firm but a news article for a rival.
- Recommending a response that the EFE does not support. The matrix should explain the choice.
- Video claims with no source. If a member cannot say where a figure came from, label it an assumption.
Need a second pair of eyes on structure before submission? Our MBA assignment help for Malaysian students covers planning and model answers for reports like this.
Student Pain Points
“Our company hardly publishes anything.” Choose a company with annual reports and Bursa Malaysia filings, or accept that the benchmark will carry more assumptions and say so openly.
“One member does everything.” Split by brief part, but agree early who owns the evidence log and who checks the EFE arithmetic. The video needs every member to know the whole argument.
“We do not know what to say when challenged.” Prepare one claim each, with the evidence behind it and the evidence that would change your mind.
“Assignment 2 is next.” Assignment 2 moves inside the firm, with VRIO, IFE and TOWS. See the Assignment 2 question page and the Assignment 2 sample to see how the external analysis you build now connects to it.
You can also browse other UNIRAZAK assignment questions for similar briefs.
FAQs
Can we choose any Malaysian company?
Yes, as long as you define one industry and one geographic market and can find public evidence for the company and two direct competitors. Check your lecturer’s rules on company choice.
How many factors should the EFE matrix have?
The brief requires at least six opportunities and threats in total. Eight to ten is common, provided each is specific and linked to earlier analysis.
How should EFE weights be set?
Give more weight to factors that can change performance more, and make the weights sum to exactly 1.00. Justify the two largest in writing.
What does an EFE total of 2.5 mean?
2.50 is the average. Above it, the firm responds better than average to external factors; below it, worse. The interpretation should name which factors drive the result.
What counts as a conflicting or incomplete source?
Two documents that give different figures for the same item, or a rival that does not disclose something you need. State both, prefer the primary filing, and mark the claim as lower confidence.
Is the video marked separately from the report?
Yes. The video carries 20 marks for the visual comparison and member defence, and every member must contribute.
Want a model layout or feedback on your draft before the 5 December 2026 deadline? Talk to our team about assignment help in Malaysia or send your brief through the submit page above.