For information and reference only – not to be submitted as your own work. This is an abridged model-answer extract showing how to critique a journal article for a master’s research methodology assessment. It does not replace your own reading of the paper you choose.
It answers the brief on our research methodology paper critique question page. For a step-by-step explanation of what markers reward, see our guide on how to approach a research methodology paper critique.
The article critiqued is a real, open-access human resource management (HRM) study: Johar et al. (2022), “COVID-19 outbreak: How do human resource management practices affect employee well-being?”, Frontiers in Psychology, 13, Article 923994, published under a Creative Commons Attribution licence. The critique is based on the published full text; always read the version you cite yourself and check every point against it. The critique is meant to be fair: the study has real strengths, and its limits are mostly those of the design.
Planning and Marks Map
| Brief part | Marks | What the extract does | Typical supporting sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Introduction to research | 20 | Defines research, tests the problem statement, significance and alignment of aim, question and hypotheses | Research methods textbooks |
| 2. Literature review evaluation | 30 | Judges relevance, the claimed gap, theory and currency of sources | Theory source, review guidance |
| 3. Ethics and politics of research | 25 | Checks participant protection, institutional and political influences, dissemination | Ethics chapters, journal policies |
| 4. Critical evaluation | 15 | Weighs strengths, reliability, implications, future research | Method-specific guidance (sampling, PLS-SEM) |
| 5. Personal reflection | 10 | Short first-person reflection (illustrative) | None required |
Buy Non Plagiarized & Properly Structured Assignment Solution
Model Answer Extract
1. Introduction to research: evaluating the article’s opening
Research can be defined as a systematic process of inquiry that collects and analyses evidence to answer a clearly stated question and add to knowledge (Bell et al., 2019; Saunders et al., 2019). The test for an introduction is therefore whether it moves from a real problem to a question that evidence can answer.
Johar et al. (2022) study how HRM practices affect the well-being of Malaysian employees during COVID-19. Their problem statement rests on the shift to working from home, with stress and financial worry, and on the argument that HR practices should match employees’ changing needs. This is a credible, timely problem, but it is stated largely in general terms. The introduction does not quantify the well-being problem among Malaysian service-sector employees, so the reader must accept the urgency from the global pandemic narrative rather than from local evidence. A sharper problem statement would cite Malaysian data on well-being or turnover.
The authors give a single research question: do ability, motivation and opportunity (AMO) practices affect employee well-being? They state the purpose as determining the extent of that impact among Malaysian employees. The question, the four hypotheses and the design line up well, because each hypothesis maps to one AMO dimension and is testable with a survey. Alignment is a strength. The weakness is breadth: “employee well-being” is treated as one outcome, although the authors themselves discuss hedonic and eudaimonic well-being as different ideas.
Significance is claimed on two fronts. Theoretically, the paper extends AMO research to well-being. Practically, it advises organisations to prioritise motivation and opportunity practices. The theoretical claim is more convincing than the practical one, since the sample is small and drawn from one region and sector.
2. Literature review evaluation
The review builds on AMO theory (Appelbaum et al., 2000), which links high-performance work practices to outcomes through employees’ skills, motivation and opportunity to contribute. This is a relevant and recognised lens for HRM. The authors argue that earlier work on HR practices and well-being used other lenses and that empirical studies linking the three AMO dimensions to well-being “were scarce”. The claimed gap is clear and the hypotheses follow from it, which is a strength.
Three limits stand out. First, the gap is argued mostly by absence (“few studies”) instead of by showing what existing results conflict or leave unexplained. Absence is a weaker justification than a contradiction in the evidence. Second, the review concentrates on HRM and well-being literature and gives limited attention to remote-work evidence, even though 88.3 per cent of respondents were working from home during the movement control order. Third, the paper does not explain why ability-enhancing practices might have little effect on well-being; the later finding that H1 was not supported therefore has no theoretical anchor beyond a short discussion.
On currency and credibility, a full critique should count how many of the paper’s sources are from the last five years and how many come from indexed journals. In your own critique, add at least one independent source to support each major claim, as the brief asks.
3. Ethics and politics of research
Survey research with employees raises standard ethical duties: informed consent, voluntary participation, anonymity or confidentiality, and privacy of responses (Bell et al., 2019). The data collection described in the paper is an online questionnaire distributed through social media, with respondents asked to pass it on to contacts in other organisations. In the full text I reviewed, I could not locate an ethics-approval statement, a consent procedure or a statement on anonymity. This does not prove that ethical procedures were skipped; some journals and institutions treat low-risk anonymous surveys differently, and the information may sit in supplementary material. It does mean the reader cannot judge compliance. Your critique should state what should have been reported: institutional approval or exemption, the consent wording, whether responses were anonymous, and how data were stored.
Snowball-style forwarding raises a further privacy point. Respondents who recruit colleagues may feel social pressure to take part, and answers about well-being and their employer’s HR practices are sensitive. Anonymity statements matter more in that setting.
On politics and influence, no funder or organisational sponsor is visible in the text I reviewed, so the main risk is not sponsor bias but publication incentives: a study reporting that three of four hypotheses were supported is easier to publish than a null finding. The authors do report H1 as not supported, which reflects reasonable transparency. On dissemination, open-access publication makes the findings available to practitioners, though the paper’s practical advice is aimed at organisations, not at the employees who provided the data.
4. Critical evaluation
| Aspect | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Design | Clear model with four hypotheses and a defined outcome | Cross-sectional, so causal direction cannot be shown |
| Sampling | Authors justify the minimum sample with a power analysis (minimum 85; 154 usable responses) | Convenience sampling from one region (Klang Valley) and sector; limits generalisation (Etikan et al., 2016) |
| Response rate | 52 per cent of 300 questionnaires reported (154 usable) | With online forwarding, the true number reached is unknown, so the rate is hard to interpret |
| Measurement | Established well-being scale and adapted AMO items on a 7-point scale | AMO items were adapted for the study; as read, Table 3 shows two retained well-being loadings (about 0.44 and 0.64) below the 0.708 level the text says was met |
| Analysis | PLS-SEM suits a small, non-normal sample (Hair et al., 2019); the authors test common method bias using full collinearity (Kock, 2015) and a marker variable | All variables are self-reported at one time, a known source of bias (Podsakoff et al., 2003) |
| Results | The model explains 42.5 per cent of variance in well-being; opportunity-enhancing practices have the largest effect | Effect sizes for extrinsic motivation are small, so practical significance is modest |
Reliability and validity are generally handled with care: the authors report discriminant validity and collinearity checks. The loading inconsistency noted above is small in a paper of this quality, but a careful reader would query it and ask whether low-loading items were kept or removed. The findings are best read as evidence of association among service-sector employees in one region at one point in 2021.
Practical implications are sensible: invest in motivation and opportunity practices and redesign training for remote work. They would be stronger with an organisational example or cost consideration. For future research, the authors suggest longitudinal and diary designs, other industries and cross-country samples. I would add a mixed-methods follow-up so that interviews can explain why ability-enhancing practices did not predict well-being.
5. Personal reflection (illustrative)
Critiquing a paper changed how I read published research. I began by checking whether the results were significant and ended up checking whether the design could support the claim. The hardest part was telling apart what a paper did not do from what it did not report, particularly on ethics. Next time I will read the supplementary material and any journal ethics policy before judging, and I will keep a log of page references so my criticism stays specific and fair.
Where to Go Next
If you are still choosing an article, use our business assignment samples to see how model answers are structured, and check the RSM5224 research proposal question for a related research methods brief. For dissertation-level support, see our thesis helper. You can also talk to our team about assignment help or submit your own brief.
References
Appelbaum, E., Bailey, T., Berg, P., & Kalleberg, A. L. (2000). Manufacturing advantage: Why high-performance work systems pay off. Cornell University Press.
Bell, E., Bryman, A., & Harley, B. (2019). Business research methods (5th ed.). Oxford University Press.
Etikan, I., Musa, S. A., & Alkassim, R. S. (2016). Comparison of convenience sampling and purposive sampling. American Journal of Theoretical and Applied Statistics, 5(1), 1–4. https://doi.org/10.11648/j.ajtas.20160501.11
Hair, J. F., Risher, J. J., Sarstedt, M., & Ringle, C. M. (2019). When to use and how to report the results of PLS-SEM. European Business Review, 31(1), 2–24. https://doi.org/10.1108/EBR-11-2018-0203
Johar, E. R., Rosli, N., Mat Khairi, S. M., Shahruddin, S., & Mat Nor, N. (2022). COVID-19 outbreak: How do human resource management practices affect employee well-being? Frontiers in Psychology, 13, Article 923994. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.923994
Kock, N. (2015). Common method bias in PLS-SEM: A full collinearity assessment approach. International Journal of e-Collaboration, 11(4), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.4018/ijec.2015100101
Podsakoff, P. M., MacKenzie, S. B., Lee, J.-Y., & Podsakoff, N. P. (2003). Common method biases in behavioral research: A critical review of the literature and recommended remedies. Journal of Applied Psychology, 88(5), 879–903. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.88.5.879
Saunders, M., Lewis, P., & Thornhill, A. (2019). Research methods for business students (8th ed.). Pearson.
Prepared by
My Assignment Help Malaysia Editorial Team
This model answer was prepared by our editorial team in response to a real assignment brief we received. It shows one way to approach the task and is meant as a study guide, not for submission.